There is a strange moment that happens as you grow older.
One day, you scroll your feed and come across an article with over 15k likes. That’s massive and the title seems interesting. Viktor Frankl, Carl Jung. You click on it.
After about a minute something turns you off. The text is formatted like a ChatGPT response. So is the title. You do not want to accuse the author, but the AI writing tics are all there. As you read on you get nauseous. It feels like eating cardboard. It sounds grandiose and it is also completely empty.
(BTW: I stole the first sentence of this post from that article.)
You can’t believe such an article gets 15k likes. So you look at the comment section. It can’t be that you are the only one. Nothing.
Then you click on the hidden comments. There they are. A few kindred spirits who share your rage and your disbelief.
But it gets worse. The profile has over 50k subscribers and the whole account seems to be run by an AI.
What on earth is going on?
Nobody Cares What You Write
The obvious conclusion is that Substack doesn’t care about your well-researched, in-depth article you sweat blood over. Just run a prompt, copy/paste and publish.
I wish I could tell you people on Substack prefer your hard-earned work over some obvious AI slop. If you had asked me a while ago I probably would have told you exactly that. But from what I have seen this would only be half true.
Before you fire yourself and hire ChatGPT to do your writing, let’s take a step back.
The account is trying to hack the system. My guess is that someone went looking for a topic with a big, hungry audience and landed on the search for meaning. Then they borrowed the authority of names everybody already trusts. Frankl and Jung do most of the work before you’ve read a single line. The whole archive is an experiment. They swap a name, change some numbers, watch what people respond to and prompt again. Do that every day or so and at some point you might win the viral lottery.
But a lottery win doesn’t give you readers. People read one of these articles. Maybe two. By the third you notice that you’re getting the same superficial stuff in a different order. The hack becomes visible. Most of the AI farm’s posts get around a hundred likes each. But there are no readers. It’s an email list at best.
I know the difference from my own subscribers. A fair share of people who discovered me through Notes have never read one of my posts. They liked my Note and subscribed. So there is a huge difference between a reader and an email address in a list.
A reader is worth something but it also takes something to get one.
Most writers want a real reader. I don’t think AI can get you one. And to be honest I have to make a confession.
Why I Wrote Empty Crap
About a year ago I published an article called “Going Viral Is A Disease”. It did pretty well. At that time it was one of my best performing articles.
It was also written by AI. I hardly changed any of it.
It was exactly the empty crap I’m attacking in this article. It’s not the only article I let AI write. But it’s the only one I published. I wanted to know whether people would notice. They didn’t. Instead they liked it.
That stinks. In fact it stinks pretty hard because that type of article does better than the ones that took me weeks to write. Hours of agonizing thinking.
(And yes, it felt good to watch it gain traction. I won’t pretend otherwise.)
What didn’t feel good was when people started to quote parts of it back to me. It gives you a weird imposter feeling because you didn’t even write those words. It gets even funnier when they ask questions about it.
Do you ask AI what it meant? Do you invent something? Then you realize you would never have written it like this. You might not even agree because it’s completely superficial.
Under one of my articles someone asked a commenter if he wrote his comment with AI. I’m pretty sure he did. It was obvious to me as well. But nobody can tell how much of it came from him. Your readers can’t see that part either. Only you can.
That’s the fucked up part. Some of the people quoting you are readers who keep coming back. They think the words came out of your own thinking. And in a way you’re letting them down. You are pretending to have made a transformation you didn’t make.
If writing it didn’t change you, it can’t change the people reading it.
They are quoting because they recognized themselves. That’s different from changing and it’s what the AI farm does: recognition.
AI Just Gives You a Mirror
That’s what a lot of people don’t get when I say that AI can’t write. They call me an AI doomer but they totally miss my point. I don’t have a problem with using AI. I use AI a lot. But it can serve as a tool only after you have written. By that I mean after you have pushed way past a shitty first draft. It takes a few rounds before you really arrive at the deeper levels.
AI works with what it is given. The paragraphs get better but you stay where you were. It hurts the people who don’t have a standpoint yet.
Using AI feels good and productive. Sometimes it even pushes back and yes, it helps you improve. So nothing tells you that something is missing.
In the end AI gives you a mirror. It hands the borrowed ideas you think are yours back to you, polished and approved.
If you think about it, that’s not much different from social media. Both business models run on your dependence. But not using them at all is just the other extreme of depending on them.
Everything you know about yourself is a piece of glass. You can use it as a mirror or as a lens. A mirror shows you yourself. A lens changes what you see. But more importantly you can point it outward to create something unique. A mirror can be useful. The problem is that most creators don’t have a lens. They have the glass but they turn it into a mirror, so they have to borrow the lens. The gurus are happy to sell you theirs. Then you see what everybody else sees and you write what everybody else writes.
Most creators have a mirror where the lens should be.
Writing helps you to develop your lens. It’s a process of finding out who you are and what you stand for. That’s what allows you to write something nobody else can. Most creators skip it. Their thinking stays in their head, so it never fully develops. AI just feeds the mirror.
Writing Is Supposed To Suck
If you just want to build an audience, you don’t have to write yourself. The AI farm is a good example.
But most people don’t want to build an audience just to make money. Yes, the money is important. But if money were all you wanted, there are easier ways to make it. Most creators want to have an impact. They want to inspire people. They want to change people.
That needs a clear standpoint. Your own lens through which you see the world. AI can’t do that for you. Writing does because writing changes you. The hours you spend staring at the blank screen are necessary.
People love the story of writing in a beautiful state of flow. You sit down. Hours pass and you feel happy. That’s mostly a myth. Ask any writer and they’ll tell you that most of the time writing sucks. (Maybe in nicer words.) I’m not going to sell you more hopium.
What I can tell you is what it did for me. A couple of months ago I wrote down one of my personal experiences and the lesson I learned from it. While writing it down I discovered more lessons that weren’t there before.
That story came up while I was staring at the wall. Okay, maybe I wasn’t actually staring at the wall. My point is that it came up when I let my mind wander. When you use AI you’re constantly engaged. Your mind never gets a chance to wander.
More than anything writing helped me find my own path. It’s how I found my voice. What I stand for and why. It’s also what my whole business is built on.
If I look back at what I wrote when I first started, I have to laugh. (Maybe cry is the better word.) It almost feels embarrassing but I wouldn’t delete it. It’s the clearest proof of my own evolution.
You're Not Doing Anything Wrong
Today AI collects likes faster than any human can write. You won’t beat it at that game. You need the hours when nothing seems to happen, staring at the wall until a story comes up.
If your last essay got five likes, it doesn’t prove you should have used AI. A lot of creators think that readers will suddenly show up after a few weeks of posting. From what I have seen, new creators shout into the void for at least six months.
My first four articles got between three and five likes. It took 33 articles and almost a year before one got more than 30.
Part of that is just how social media works. So many people are trying to become creators. You can’t expect to get seen by thousands of people just by showing up once in a while. But “consistency is king” is only half true. If you post every day without a lens you end up with an email list.
Many creators draw the wrong conclusion from the void. In the beginning they are too concerned with providing value and helping people make money. It keeps them stuck in overthinking. Or it might even work. But in the end they are just clones and a clone is replaceable.
For me there was more to it. I didn’t think about providing value with my writing. I needed the time to figure out my path. Writing is how you find out who you are.
You only ever know who you are once you have written it.
You see gurus with thousands of followers telling you how to make money with your writing. Does that mean you should write about making money too? No, because that is their lens. AI has conquered the how-to genre. Does that mean you should use AI? No, because it only gives you the same mirror the thousands of other creators see.
To figure out your story you have to write it. That’s how you develop your own lens.
So if you’re getting three likes right now, you’re not doing anything wrong. You’re in the middle of figuring out who you are. Yes, at times it’s going to suck. That’s the price. The payoff is that one day someone tells you that you changed their life and they didn’t quote AI.
Your story can only be written by you. Go write it.
P.S. Everything in this article points to the same problem. Most creators borrow a lens because they have no words for the way they naturally create. I created The Archetype Navigator to help you with that.
It’s free and takes less than five minutes to uncover your natural pattern, so you can build a body of work that looks like you. It might save you years of writing what everybody else writes.




I’m still early in my journey and I love reading posts like this, because it expresses thoughts that we newbies battle with but dare not say yet until we have gained more traction 🥰. I love your advice that it takes time to find your voice. I can see what it is emerging now that I have a few posts published under my belt. “Before you fire yourself and hire ChatGPT to do your writing, let’s take a step back” did give me a good giggle. 🙏🥰💛
This is an excellent post Phillip. I couldn't find a word I disagree with. We need not be complete AI deniers but we must write our own voice.